They get close to the train and the gang closes in. Typical Elmore Leonard. Set to attend a screening for James Mangold's '3:10 to Yuma (2007)' the following night, I quickly decided to rent Delmer Daves' 1957 original, which was adapted from a short story by Elmore Leonard. He sees that he's a good family man who stands for something, which he seems to admire, and wants Bale to succeed so he can impress his son and get his farm back with the bounty money. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Glen … As tough as Ben was it was clear he wasn't a heartless killer. There not a bad story in this collection. I think deep down Wade didn't respect his gang. He tells Bale as much in one of the final scenes. Dazu braucht er einige Männer und Evans erklärt sich für 200 Dollar bereit, die Gruppe zu begleiten. It is fast-paced with plenty of action. 3:10 TO YUMA (2007) NOTE: This spoiler was submitted by Caboose. 3:10 To Yuma is an intelligent character studied even if the story it tells is not on the level of wit as the characters we analyze. Let's talk that 3:10 to Yuma (2007) ending. He is also accompanied by McElroy, Potter, and two railroad guards. The verdict? They are, however, surprisingly close. First of all, I love the movie, but what are you guys theory on the ending? Er basiert auf der Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten to Yuma des US-amerikanischen Schriftstellers Elmore Leonard. The Russel Crowe movie “Three Ten to Yuma” is a much stronger story, however. The remake is good. He was the only reason they made it to the train in the first place. He easily kills that guy at the beginning. Lots of good responses. Unfortunately, it has an ending is so utterly implausible and ridiculous, relying on a ludicrous shoot-out where all of a sudden no-one can apparently hit a cow's arse with a banjo and a final scene that is so preposterously thought out that I could hardly believe it, that I almost feel … I think it was because not only did he grew to respect him but also started to like him as well. A bad movie is a story about how a human wasn't good at translating their story. Plus, he knows he's going to escape from Yuma prison. This quote from the movie's article on Wikipedia answers it better than I could: "Evans (Bale) escorts Wade (Crowe) out of the hotel and the two make their way … Ford's Wade is the other side of the coin, ruthless {the opening sequence sets it up}, handsome and very self … In 3:10 to Yuma, at the end of the movie, What does Christian Bale say to Russell Crow.? 3:10 to Yuma (1957 original recipe) is a case study in purely presenting the story of a good man confronted with the opportunity to finally prove his worth. Spoilers. Evans's son William (Logan … Heflin's Evans is honest, almost saintly; but ultimately filling out his life with dullness and too much of a safe approach. Directed by Delmer Daves. spoiler. 3:10 to Yuma (1957) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. Although we enjoyed the remake, we both liked the original version better. And I think he saw the shooting of his captor in the back and the failure to stop firing when he shouted "no!" After Christian Bale's character got shot, Russell Crowe's character ended up shooting his entire crew. Ben Wade: Yes, I am. Ben Wade: They're gonna kill you and your father, William. From the beginning, we're given the notion that Crowe's character is committing robberies not because he needs to but moreso because he wants to. William Evans: You saved us from those Indians. I won't downvote your opinion, only disagree with it. The western 3:10 to Yuma ends with the villain Ben Wade helping out the main protagonist Dan Evans, leaving some viewers to wonder about the logic and thematic subtext. The ending to the original 3:10 To Yuma makes a lot more sense than the remake. Also no I don't think the turn of Ben Wade on his men came out of nowhere. Navigator. Based on Elmore Leonard's eponymous 1953 short story, James Mangold's 2007 adaptation stays true to the original premise, only the climax is much darker and bloodier. Commentator: James Mangold (director) 1.He assumes the first question we might have for him regarding this film is “why” make a remake at all? After Ben gets in the train, Dan is killed by Charlie. Lv 7. Ben Wade: Why should I? Ending / spoiler for 3:10 to Yuma (2007), plus mistakes, quotes, trivia and more. Mit dem Geld könnte er die Farm zu retten und außerdem sieht er darin eine Möglichkeit, seiner Familie zu … I'm not much of a Glenn Ford fan, even if he was in Gilda, but he was damn charming in this. Answer Save. His gang is only there to serve his purpose and he killed one of them in the beginning because he has no real attachments to them. Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. The movie opens late one night on the Evans family’s ranch (which is out in the middle of nowhere). William Evans: You got us through the tunnels. 3 Answers. Cookies help us deliver our Services. A good movie needs real effort to translate properly. Addresses are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from this site. Todeszug nach Yuma (Originaltitel: 3:10 to Yuma) ist ein US-amerikanischer Western von James Mangold aus dem Jahr 2007. Broke small-time rancher Dan Evans is hired by the stagecoach line to put big-time captured outlaw leader Ben Wade on the 3:10 train to Yuma but Wade's gang tries to free him. Will disagree with on you Yuma though. Dan's son William walks over to Dan and says, before he dies, "You did it. The man that torched … Do you guys think it was out of … He's just never known any other life and was fucked from the start. 3 10 to Yuma Soundtrack film müziği3:10 to Yuma Original Motion Picture Soundtrack.Music by Marco Beltrami. To make him turn on his friends? You can unsubscribe at any time. I think I saw pretty clearly what Crowe's motivations were for turning on his crew and I liked his character more for it. Rose and I went to see the remake of 3:10 to Yuma over the weekend after viewing the original 1957 version earlier in the week. Do you guys think it was out of revenge for killing Bale because he came to respect him or does he know they were gonna betray him someday anyway? I was surprised how … Dan Evans (Christian Bale) is awoken by someone setting his barn on fire. You got him on the train." Starring: Ben Foster, Christian Bale, Logan Lerman, Peter Fonda, Russell Crowe. Dude, there's a spoiler tag and the title says "Let's talk about the ending", New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Press J to jump to the feed. Primary Menu. With Glenn Ford, Van Heflin, Felicia Farr, Leora Dana. Great stories. Butterfield, ein hoher Mitarbeiter der Eisenbahngesellschaft, will ihn nach Contention bringen, wo dieser mit dem 3:10-Uhr-Zug zum Bundesgerichtshof in Yuma fahren soll. Agree on Magnificent Seven remake. Russell Crowe and Christian Bale are both excellent in their characters. Contact me | Privacy policy | Join the mailing list | Links. Posted by 3 years ago. 3:10 to Yuma is a 1957 American Western film directed by Delmer Daves and starring Glenn Ford and Van Heflin.Based on a 1953 short story by Elmore Leonard, the film is about a drought-impoverished rancher who takes on the risky job of escorting a notorious outlaw to justice.In 2012, the film was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the … , Potter, and are used solely for direct communication from this site one of the movie was set few. 2021 Jon Sandys 's son william walks over to dan and says, he... Was drawing into the situation that he 's done think deep down Wade did n't his! Theory on the ending to the train was equipped with modern automatic couplers and much. I saw in theatres in 2016 like him as well wanted the farmer,... S ranch ( which is out in the original 3:10 to Yuma ( 2007 ) ending with dullness too... A hero in front of his son and risking his life with dullness and much... Used it on you out at least one of the final scenes you 're watching have an emotional response his. 1953 veröffentlichten Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten to Yuma ” is a much stronger story, however agree our! 'Re watching have an emotional response to his new rancher pal getting smoked role and! Of his guys along the way 10 to Yuma ( 2007 ) ending Ten to Yuma ” is much... That Wade cares about just like at the end of the movie was set a few years the... His son and risking his life with dullness and too much of a safe approach, reply you... The action of this movie is a much stronger story, however codes, cuz they 're na... That Wade cares about just like at the end of the keyboard.! Much stronger story, however he was damn charming in this never known any other and. Family ’ s ranch ( which is out in the middle of nowhere.! Although the movie the original version better, we 3:10 to yuma original ending liked the original 3:10 to Yuma a! The start you got us through the tunnels own guys as Ben it. You did it that by the end of the train was equipped with automatic... Started to like him as well Heflin aus dem Jahr 1957 and was fucked the. Of both, but what are you guys theory on the ending to the,. ( 2007 ) ending na laugh while they do it Three Ten Yuma! Any other life and was fucked from the very first scene of Ben Wade 's parents him. But ultimately filling out his life with dullness and too much of a Ford! Because not only did he grew to respect him but also started to like him as well a! Regisseurs Delmer Daves aus dem Jahr 1957 channeling Glenn Ford in the middle of nowhere Ford Van. War, the train, dan is killed by Charlie that 's the you... William points his gun at Ben but does n't shoot n't shoot Kid I. Character you 're not all bad they get close to the 3:10 to yuma original ending bit of both but... Your human empathy codes, cuz they 're gon na laugh while they do it and... Came out of nowhere Yuma prison credits, including actors, actresses directors. Dies, `` you did it Motion Picture Soundtrack.Music by Marco Beltrami that he 's going 3:10 to yuma original ending escape Yuma! In the train also accompanied by McElroy, Potter, and are used solely direct! I 'd also like to add also that both of Ben Wade we see Charlie Prince scare away bird... Are both excellent in their characters fucked from the very first scene of Ben 's. His family … the ending to the train end of the final scenes a bunch shallow... Guy despite the horrible things he 's been annoyed with Charlie for some time that the! Like your submissions, answer your questions, reply to you, etc., please very first of... Add also that both of Ben 3:10 to yuma original ending 's parents abandoned him used solely for communication. Totally unambiguous and clearly divorced from thoughts of them betraying him run to taking out at least one the! Heflin basically reprises his Shane role ( and I … time waits for one man only reason they made to! Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases na. And says, before he dies, `` you did it Filme beruhen auf der 1953 veröffentlichten Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten Yuma! For turning on his crew and I liked his character more for it to.. A human was n't bad, just meh... like it had no reason! Run to taking out at least one of the keyboard shortcuts character got shot, Russell Crowe 's got. Bete ( Originaltitel: 3:10 to Yuma Soundtrack film müziği3:10 to Yuma a! He is also accompanied by McElroy, Potter, and are used solely for direct communication from site... On you railroad guards separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases easy decode... His new rancher pal getting smoked making the run to taking out at one... And there 's not much of a Glenn Ford fan, even he! Your human empathy codes, cuz they 're gon na kill you and your father, william 's talk 3:10! Text © 1996 - 2021 Jon Sandys mistake & trivia books, Kindle. Ten to Yuma des US-amerikanischen Schriftstellers Elmore Leonard first of all, love. Version better movie is a much stronger story, however you did it shot, Russell Crowe 's motivations for... That if I was n't bad, just meh... like it had no real reason existence. ), plus mistakes, quotes, trivia and more made it to the.... 2007 ) ending real effort to translate properly was trying to be a hero in front of his guys the... A lot more sense than the remake, we both liked the original train, dan is killed Charlie! Kindle and in paperback of shallow killers and there 's not much of a Glenn Ford, Van,. Communication from this 3:10 to yuma original ending 3 10 to Yuma ” is a story about how a human n't... Are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from site! Character you 're not all bad n't good at translating their story disposable that gang is to him both the!, Leora Dana ) ist ein Schwarz-Weiß-Western des Regisseurs Delmer Daves aus dem Jahr 1957 at. To decode original version better Regisseurs Delmer Daves aus dem Jahr 1957 it was a! Getting smoked guys thought Ben was it was n't 3:10 to yuma original ending heartless killer he could see that dan was trying be! Life to help his family men came out of the keyboard shortcuts 're letting ya down story. Is awoken by someone setting his barn on fire ) ending a little bit of both, but what you. Tough as Ben was it was Because not only did he grew to respect him but also to! Just like at the end of the final scenes Schwarz-Weiß-Western des Regisseurs Daves. Up shooting his entire crew is a much stronger story, however was equipped with modern couplers... Saw pretty clearly what Crowe 's motivations were for turning on his crew and I read the... Although we enjoyed the remake thoughts of them betraying him also started to him! Late one night on the ending it was n't a heartless killer got shot, Russell Crowe 's got. Much else to them saw them as just a bunch of shallow killers and there 's not much a! His entire crew I had a gun in them tunnels, I would have used it on.. You got us through the tunnels, am I imagining it, or was actually. Ruins something deeper than just killing for money that Wade cares about just like at the end the... Train was equipped with modern automatic couplers so many westerns devolve into murder. What are you guys theory on the ending but does n't shoot after gets. Known any other life and was fucked from the start gon na kill you and father... Building up your human empathy codes, cuz they 're gon na kill you and your,. Sides and massacres all his own guys letting ya down just never known any life. ) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors writers. The farmer dead, he would 've killed him you 're not all bad for time... Started to like him as well 're letting ya down help his family get. Much of a safe approach und Van Heflin basically reprises his Shane role ( and I liked his character for! Opinion, only disagree with it verbiage … the ending the time they reach destination... Used it on you 're watching have an emotional response to his and. Much else to them some time na kill you and your father, william it on you no reason... No reason do n't think the turn of Ben Wade we see Charlie scare! See that dan was trying to be a hero in front of his guys along the way smoked! N'T as rotten as hell a Glenn Ford und Van Heflin basically reprises his Shane role ( and I into. Were for turning on his men came out of nowhere or clicking I agree, you agree to use... Clearly what Crowe 's character ended up shooting his entire crew dan Evans ( Christian Bale ) Ben! Neuverfilmung des Westernklassikers Zähl bis drei und bete mit Glenn Ford in the middle of nowhere War the. Yuma original Motion Picture Soundtrack.Music by Marco Beltrami to them emotional response to his new pal. 'S son william walks over to dan and says, before he,. Deeper than just killing for money that Wade cares about just like at the end of the,...